How to Choose the Right Enamel Pin Finish for Your Collection

By ToyShnip - Online Store for Collectibles, Toys, Pop Culture | EN | Published: 2026-10-20

Category: Product Reviews

Learn the differences between hard and soft enamel pins, and get practical decision rules to pick the right finish for your collection.

Quick Answer

Choose hard enamel for a smooth, durable, glass-like finish that resists scratches, and soft enamel for a textured, budget-friendly look with vibrant recessed colors.

Hard Enamel vs Soft Enamel: What’s the Difference?

Hard enamel pins are filled with enamel that is baked and then polished flat, creating a smooth, glass-like surface that is highly scratch-resistant. Soft enamel pins leave the metal borders raised and the enamel slightly recessed, giving a textured feel that catches light and adds depth.

The choice between them often comes down to how you plan to use the pin. If you’ll wear it on a bag or jacket that gets daily wear, hard enamel’s durability is a major advantage. If you prefer a more tactile, dimensional look and want to keep costs lower, soft enamel is a solid option.

Other Finish Factors to Consider

Beyond the enamel type, look at the metal base and plating. Die-cast zinc alloy with a nickel-plated finish, like many FiGPiN pins, offers a sturdy feel and a shiny border that resists tarnishing. This is a good sign of overall build quality.

Also consider the pin’s size and thickness. Larger pins, such as those around 3 inches, give artists more room for detail, but they can be heavier. If you plan to attach the pin to delicate fabric, a lighter, smaller pin might be more practical.

Decision Rules for Choosing Your Pin Finish

If you want maximum durability: Choose hard enamel. The polished surface resists scratches and chips, making it ideal for pins you’ll wear daily or attach to bags and jackets. Check for a smooth, glass-like surface to confirm hard enamel.
If you prefer a textured, dimensional look: Choose soft enamel. The recessed color and raised metal lines create depth and catch light, giving the pin a more tactile feel. Run your finger over the pin—if you feel ridges, it’s soft enamel.
If you’re on a budget but still want quality: Soft enamel is generally more affordable, but still offers good detail and color. Look for a sturdy metal base, like die-cast zinc alloy, to ensure longevity. Compare prices per pin and check the metal base material.
If you plan to display your pins: Hard enamel’s smooth surface reflects light nicely under glass, and larger pins with detailed art, like the Star Wars A New Hope series, make great display pieces. Consider a pin stand or case to protect the finish.

Pins That Showcase Different Finishes

FiGPiN Enamel Pin - Marvel The Falcon And The Winter Soldier - Select Figure(s): The FiGPiN Marvel Falcon and Winter Soldier pins are made with layered hard enamel over die-cast zinc alloy with a nickel-plated finish. This construction gives a smooth, durable surface that can handle frequent handling and wear without losing its shine.
FiGPiN Enamel Pin - Marvel The Falcon And The Winter Soldier - Select Figure(s)
FiGPiN Enamel Pin - Star Wars - A New Hope - Select Figure(s): The FiGPiN Star Wars A New Hope pins are approximately 3 inches wide and 2mm thick, with a polycarbonate case and backer stand. The larger size and protective case make these pins ideal for display, while the thickness adds a substantial feel.
FiGPiN Enamel Pin - Star Wars - A New Hope - Select Figure(s)

Which Finish Fits You?

Best for

Collectors who wear pins on bags, jackets, or lanyards and need scratch resistance
Fans who prefer a smooth, polished look that photographs well

Not for

Those who love the textured, recessed look of soft enamel and don’t mind a less durable surface
Budget-focused buyers who want the lowest cost per pin